Closed orbits, conserved quantities, and symmetries in the Kepler problem
In some cases, unexpectedly deep connections allow far-reaching conclusions to be drawn from commonplace observations. This post provides an example of such an occurrence. A readily observable fact about the orbits of bound celestial objects is that they regularly repeat. Closed orbits are not only prevalent in the solar system, but can also be directly observed, for instance, in visual binary stars, as shown in the figure below. This simple observation places strong constraints on the nature of the gravitational force. Observed orbit projected in the plane of the sky of the secondary component of the Sirius system relative to the primary (open and filled circles represent data obtained with different techniques, as detailed in the legend; the black filled circle at the origin marks the position of the primary). The best-fitting orbit is shown by the black line (data and orbital solution from Bond et al. 2017, ApJ 840, 70). A somewhat obscure theorem of classical mecha...